Many patients living with chronic pain, migraines or arthritis are convinced that their pain is influenced by the weather.

They may say things like,

“I knew it was going to rain today cause all my joints are sore.”

 “Whenever there is a change in air pressure, my body pains get worse.”

As reported by those living with chronic pain, roughly…

  • 1 in 10 are sensitive to the temperature
  • 1 in 25 are sensitive to relative humidity
  • 1 in 50 are sensitive to pressure
  • 3 in 100 are sensitive to wind speed

(Yimer et al 2022)

There’s no debate that for some individuals, the weather influences their pain. The debate is if the worsening of the pain is actually related to barometric pressures or if it is a conditioned response.

So, they’ve done studies on this. For this first study, they recruited patients with chronic arthritis who strongly believed that the weather outside affected their pain. Over a 12-month period, they tracked their daily pain ratings and compared them to actual weather conditions.

“We studied patients for more than 1 year and found no statistically significant associations between their arthritis pain and the weather conditions implicated by each individual.” – Redelmeir et al 1996

This means that when the subjects in this study experienced pain on rainy days, they blamed the weather even though they experienced similar flare-ups on sunny days.

On the other hand, this 2019 study followed over 2600 people with chronic pain who lived in England (where they have plenty of rainy days)… and they humorously named  the study, “Cloudy with a Chance of Pain”.

Using a phone app, for over a year, they collected data and found that weather WAS associated with increased pain the following day.

“The analysis has demonstrated significant relationships between relative humidity, pressure, wind speed and pain” – Dixon et al 2019

 We now have two conflicting studies. Now what?

Well, this 2022 paper based on 13,000 participants concluded that…

“… there is no definite indication that participants’ underlying pain conditions play a role in weather sensitivity.” – Yimer et al 2022

 When it comes to migraines, many swear that certain weathers and temperatures trigger their agonizing symptoms.

This 14-yearlong study in Spain, analyzed over 3000 migraine consultations and concluded that temperature, barometric pressure, wind speed and other weather variables were NOT predictive of migraines.

 

So, what’s the verdict now?

This is where a few theories regarding the relationship between weather & pain are proposed.

Is it possible that the association between weather and increased pain intensity is a conditioned response?

Perhaps when pain is worse on a rainy day, the brain notices and remembers it and coincides it with pain.

On the other hand, when it is a sunny day and there is pain, the brain is less likely to associate it with the weather, so a conditioned response does not occur.

Despite the controversy, it seems like for most people cold weather, rain and clouds do not consistently worsen chronic pain.

However, there is little debate that a lack of sunlight can increase sensitivity of an already hypersensitive nervous system.

 

What is the solution to weather-associated pains or migraines?

We obviously cannot control the weather, but we may be able to change how we respond to weather changes… in other words, we can focus on eliminating the conditioned response.

Step #1: Patients must first accept the idea that it is not the weather, but their brains conditioned response to a weather that increases their symptoms.

“Bad” weather –> Danger –> PAIN

If the brain expects something to happen, it will alter physiology to make it happen!

The solution is to consciously become aware of this expectation association

Step #2: Patients must believe that this conditioned response can be UNLEARNED!

“Bad” weather –> Safe –> No change in PAIN

The goal is to weaken the association with consistent conscious practice. This is achieved by learning and accepting that cold weather is just cold weather.

This is not positive thinking… it is accurate thinking.

The other option is to move to Florida, Arizona, Mexico, Spain, etc. (Sadly, people there also experience pain ☹)

IMPORTANT NOTE: Although UNLEARNING is not easy, it’s certainly possible!

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

0